My 4 Biggest Homeschooling Mistakes

Confession is good for the soul, right?  Well as much as I would love to tell you what a great homeschooling mom I am and how many things I’ve done right along the way in my homeschooling journey, the fact is, I’ve made a lot of mistakes, too.

A lot of mistakes.

blonde woman with shocked look on her face

Now I’ve tried to learn from each and every one of them.  In that sense, mistakes can be valuable and even fortunate, if they drive us to make changes, do things differently, and do them better.  And if I can also share an experience and it helps prevent someone else from making the same error, then my mistake has been doubly worthwhile!

Now I won’t bother you with the minor mistakes here because those could go on forever.  (You know, like buying Disney princess pencils over Ticonderogas.  Never, ever again.)  Instead let me just tell you the four BIGGEST mistakes I have made since I began homeschooling:

Mistake #1:  Trying very hard to make homeschool look like public school

Dumb, DUMB thing to do, I realize now, but when all you’ve ever known is public school, ridding yourself of that PS thinking can be really, really hard.  I wasn’t so crazy as to implement a bell system or demand my kids carry a hall pass to the bathroom, but I still thought very much in public school terms:  Learning was about structure, structure, structure.  Kids were supposed to be doing the same things in the same way at the same age.  Tests were really the only proper way to evaluate a child’s learning.  Reading and answering questions and memorizing were the best ways to learn.  Period. 

Except that all of that was thoroughly, fundamentally WRONG.

Putting homeschooling in a “public school box” limits learning potential in some unbelievable ways.  I only wish I could have thrown off some of my public school inhibitions sooner!

Mistake #2:  Putting far too much confidence in a curriculum

Now you have to understand how this one particular curriculum had been touted to me.  I had listened to a few homeschoolers praise it as the be-all, end-all homeschooling curriculum, (even though none of them had ever tried anything else, I found out later,) and they insisted I would see remarkable progress in my children if I would just use this curriculum!

And then, (looking back to mistake #1 for a minute here,) I glanced over the curriculum myself and found it very structured and very similar to what I had encountered in public school.  So it was perfect, right?

WRONG.  I hated it.  My children hated it.  It was such a miserable fit for our family and a disastrous starting place for a child I would later learn was dyslexic.  By the time I suffered through that curriculum I was ready to quit homeschooling altogether.  I mean, if I couldn’t make such a fabulous curriculum work, then obviously I wasn’t fit to homeschool, right?

Of course with time I learned there is not a homeschooling curriculum in the world that is perfect for every child or every mom or every learning style.  I only wish I had recognized our struggles and been willing to make changes sooner.  There is no miracle curriculum.  And while I realize you can’t change curricula like you change your socks, if something isn’t working, sometimes you have to be willing to make adjustments, no matter how “fabulous” the curriculum is supposed to be, who else uses it, or how much you paid for it.

Mistake #3:  Pushing my kids too early

I think deep inside me there was this prideful little monster who wanted my children reading Shakespeare individually at age 3 or doing trigonometry at age 5.  Not that any kid really needs to read Shakespeare at 3 or do trig at 5, mind you, but sometimes we’re looking for a little ego boost, and an academically advanced child can provide that.

And I think I gave into other pressures, too.  I mean, several of my friends had kids who were excelling academically, not to mention the fact I was new to homeschooling and felt the need to validate myself as a capable teacher.

But I pushed my kids, (my dyslexic daughter in particular, God, forgive me,) to learn things they weren’t ready for and weren’t interested in, and in doing so I did more to delay learning than to really encourage it.  When I stopped pushing and allowed my kids to progress at their own pace, I found they learned more quickly, retained things more fully, and enjoyed the learning process far more.

Mistake #4:  Expecting my kids to learn like I learn

Fortunately, this was one of those things I was able to learn fairly quickly.  In fact, at the very outset I probably would have told you that I knew it already — that my kids would never learn just like I learn – and yet I found it so frustrating when they didn’t!

I wish my kids could share my interests and absorb information the same way I do.  That would definitely make homeschooling easier for me.  Instead I’ve had to use resources and approaches that don’t necessarily appeal to my own way of thinking, and I’ve had to learn to twist my own thought processes to find new ways to help me drive home information.


The awesome thing about it, none of these were mistakes I could not overcome.  I definitely wish I had overcome them sooner, but had I never made them, there are so many wonderful aspects of homeschooling I may never have discovered.  And that’s probably true of most of us as homeschooling moms.  Our mistakes are good overall, because they lead us to better things.

What would you consider your biggest mistakes in your homeschooling journey?   



About the author

Guest Blogger


Click here to post a comment

  • Thanks so much for sharing this! I have made similar mistakes and it’s good to reflect and be also be encouraged by other moms in the same situation.

    • We ALL make so many mistakes, though we’re not generally excited to talk about them! But I’ve honestly learned so much from the things I’ve done wrong over the years, though I certainly wish I could have learned the lessons sooner and easier. I think the important thing is be willing to own up to mistakes, make the necessary changes, and then share with others so hopefully they can avoid doing the same!

  • Very inspiring notes and thanks for sharing, my wife and I start thinking about homeschooling and it is great to learn from someone’s experience. Thank you Tanya and hello from Hong Kong,


    • You’re so welcome! I hope you’ll give homeschooling a try! Hip Homeschool Moms will always be here offering encouragement and ideas. 🙂

  • I am starting homeschooling with my kids this year after my kids going to publoc school until now. My son is dyslexic and I wondered what worked best for your daughter?

    • My daughter really began to improve when we slowed down and took more of a Charlotte Mason approach, primarily in the area of language arts. If you aren’t familiar with Charlotte Mason, a little research will turn up more information than you likely know what to do with! I read to her a lot, allowing her to narrate back orally rather than writing everything she had learned. It seemed to help her so much to learn how to collect her thoughts and express them in a way that was understandable. In fact, we STILL do a lot of her work orally. Learning to read was a slow, sometimes painful process, but she has improved until at 12 she’s a much more confident reader with good comprehension, and she’s becoming a better writer as well. It’s still a work in progress, but we have come so far. Every child is different of course, and what works for one may not work for another, but I definitely encourage a slower, more relaxed approach when you’re dealing with a dyslexic. In my experience at least, the intense, highly structured curricula tend to overwhelm quickly.

      I realize that answer is so general, but I hope it can give you some direction at least. I wish you the best in homeschooling and I hope you see wonderful progress in your son!